Reviews For Goodbye, Mr. Giles
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Michelle Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 09/04/2007 - 12:19 pm Title: Chapter 34 ~ Thoughts, A Penny's Worth

Thanks for the update. This is one of my favorite stories. I'm always happy to see a new chapter! I love your characterizations -- you bring such depth to everyone, not just Spike and Buffy.


Author's Response: HI Michelle, Thank YOU for the kind words.

Reviewer: JO Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/18/2007 - 12:57 am Title: Chapter 33 ~ Old Times, Old Friends, Old Problems...with a twist

Okay , I no longer want to pop Spike one in the nose ( after all i'm mad for him) I gladhe realizes how dumb he was being and hurtful, but how come neither vampire could sense wjo was behind the cottage, dum de dum dum, I will tune in next chapter to find out .

Author's Response: HI JO, You know, I would have sworn that I already answered you. Well, life has been bedlam, so I guess I just imagined it.. Sincere apologies. Of course, the simple answer is that Binnemon is not as inept a vampire as we might suspect. But, I think both vampires sensed a vampire and when they saw each other assumed the other was the vamp they sensed.

Reviewer: guest Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/17/2007 - 03:52 pm Title: Chapter 33 ~ Old Times, Old Friends, Old Problems...with a twist

Loved it. I was wondering when there was going to be another chapter. This is one of my favorite spuffy stories.

can't wait to read more

Author's Response: Whew, I'm afraid I've been a really bad person. Your comment has been here since July and I'm only now responding. Well, at least that gives you an idea of how wacko my life has been this summer. Hopefully I can give you more regular updates now that summer is over and life will return to a dull roar instead of utter chaos.

Reviewer: jamies_lady Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/16/2007 - 10:07 pm Title: Chapter 33 ~ Old Times, Old Friends, Old Problems...with a twist

wonderful and well worth the wait. loved the way you explained Buffy waiting for him to come round, really really clever.
looking forward to next update

Author's Response: Thank you so much, m'lady. I've made so many apologies to so many for the delay in updates and can only keep asking for understanding as REAL LIFE keeps getting in the way. Thanks so much for your comment.

Reviewer: SpaceLord Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/16/2007 - 09:34 pm Title: Chapter 33 ~ Old Times, Old Friends, Old Problems...with a twist

Well love the story but have a hard time believing that a mere "fledge" would be able to go undetected by Spike. Guess it's in the best interest of the story but still find that hard to buy.

Author's Response: Hi SpaceLord, I struggled with that a bit myself. I convinced myself that it would work because, after all, Binne isn't really a fledge. In fact, he had a one on one unlife with his sire for many, many years. But that's not the real reason I think it works. Rather, Spike has other very important things on his mind. The threat he perceived seemed to have been resolved when he ran into MacGregor. Following that encounter, Spike went right back in the cottage and as I said, both vampires, sensing the other...failed to sense yet another. I appreciate your comment.

Reviewer: JO Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/01/2007 - 11:32 am Title: Chapter 32 ~ Friends, Family, Facts

I've been waiting for this update forever, he was contrite enough for me it satisfied my bitchy self , but I still want to pop him one. Can't wait til their alone.

Author's Response: Hi Jo, I'm sorry it took forever. Darn real life keeps getting in the way. Like he said, he's been selfish and it took Xander to help him see things the right way. Don't be too hard on him. He's trying. Thanks for your comment.

Reviewer: guest Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/01/2007 - 06:26 am Title: Chapter 32 ~ Friends, Family, Facts

oh yes, spike and buffy made up. finally.

i really love this story. I will be waiting for the next chapter.

Author's Response: Good Lord willin' it shouldn't be nearly as long. The betas already have the next chapter. I'm so glad you're enjoying. Thanks.

Reviewer: jamies_lady Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/01/2007 - 06:11 am Title: Chapter 32 ~ Friends, Family, Facts

what made Spike realsie what he'd been doing?
loved the update many thanks

Author's Response: I think he knew all along, but was helpless to do something about it, being so caught up in his own worries about himself. Ultimately, of course, it was Xander. I'm glad you're enjoying. Thanks for commenting.

Reviewer: All4Spike Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 06/15/2007 - 04:15 pm Title: Chapter 31 ~ Confession

I can't believe I've only just found this excellent fic!
I just love the whole Slayer School thing, and Xander becoming Watcher junior. So glad both he and Giles have come to terms with Buffy & Spike being together.. and may I say ouch on Spike's behalf? Why on earth doesn't he just tell Buffy what he's thinking? Poor girl... Xander's right, he should tell the doc too, she prolly hasn't connected up all the parts... might not realise they need to be connected...
I expect Dawn will sort him out.

Author's Response: Hi All4Spike, Welcome. I'm so pleased you're enjoying. I promise, it wll all be resolved eventually, but not necessarily as you think. There are still lots of surprises.

Reviewer: guest Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 06/04/2007 - 03:15 pm Title: Chapter 31 ~ Confession

exactly, sex is an important thing in their relationship. So, he is aftraid to disappoint buffy. You never want to disappoint the ones that you love. And that is why spike is scared to tell buffy. I'm not saying that spike is right and not telling buffy. Cause you always got to be honest when it comes to things like that. But I can understand why it is taking him a little longer to tell her. I think we all had something to tell somebody that took us a while to tell someone. And we should have told them sooner. That is all i'm saying.

And no more angst please. can we get with the spuffy lovin soon.

Author's Response: Mmmmmm...Spuffy lovin' Thanks again.

Reviewer: JO Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 06/04/2007 - 01:17 pm Title: Chapter 31 ~ Confession

Im so glad you updated , been watching for it , but this chaptter was a tease ,I hope I don't have to wait to long for the next one , I'm hoping for a big reconciliation, although I think she should make him suffer a littlle emotional angst first.

Author's Response: Oy! You're hoping for more angst? Haven't they suffered enough? Nah! Thanks for the comment. Honestly, will try to be quicker. *G*

Reviewer: jamies_lady Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 06/04/2007 - 06:50 am Title: Chapter 31 ~ Confession

way to go Xander, someone had to tell it as it was. i only hope Spike listened. Loved this and am looking forward to more

Author's Response: Turns out that Xander has a pair too!*G*

Reviewer: guest Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 06/04/2007 - 04:08 am Title: Chapter 31 ~ Confession

well, I don't know if I would agree with Xander and how he treated spike. I didn't get that Spike was saying that all buffy wanted from him was the great sex. And I think he was just afraid that she would be disappointed. And that is why he was scared of seeing if he can still perform like he use to. Not that all buffy wanted was great sex from him.

that is my opinion at least.



Author's Response: I think it's kind of the same thing. Spike knows that Buffy loves him, but the sex IS an important part of their relationship. He doesn' t want to disappoint her. Xander is saying that the only thing that matters is that Buffy loves him and Spike needed a reminder. Remember, there will always be a bit of timid, unsure William lurking somewhere in Spike. Thanks for the comment.

Reviewer: Toni Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 06/04/2007 - 03:59 am Title: Chapter 31 ~ Confession

Hooray for Xander and his big mouth!!

Author's Response: Xander has always been expert at the judgemental stuff, only this time he's right.

Reviewer: sister cuervo Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/25/2007 - 12:04 am Title: Chapter 26~ Investigation, Interrogation, Insinuation

Excellent chapters, leaving me breathless for the next. The entire story is so well done: plenty of action, romance and interesting, well fleshed-out original characters.
Thanks for writing.

Author's Response: Oh! Hooray! Thank you so much, my sister. Thank you for reading, I am so happy you are enjoying.

Reviewer: Mrs X Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/18/2007 - 05:47 am Title: Chapter 30~ Crimes of the Heart

I read this story, and I like it, but for some reason I haven't reviewed yet. Shame on me, I know writers need to know they are appreciated. Well, I'm doing it now and I just have to tell you that I look forward to every chapter.

This isn't your run-of-the-mill Spuffy story, no this is something much better. It has depth of the more unusual kind, both when it comes to characterization and to placing it in the real world, so to speak. Blending the supernatural with the mundane is one of the strenghts of your story. Another is the complexity of Spike and Buffy as individuals as well as their relationship. I also very much enjoy that this is an ensemble fic and I have developed a very warm relationship with "your" Giles.

Keep up the good work. I'm confident you won't disappoint me.

Author's Response: Mrs X, Wouldn't it be a wonderful world for writers if everyone who read, commented. My stats say that 949 people have read (well, clicked and opened anyway)so I should have that many comments. The nice thing is that nearly every chapter someone new signs on, so I don't believe I've lost the others, just found new friends. Your kind of review is the most satisfying ... certainly that it is complementary, but more because it is evident that you have invested yourself in the story. That means so much and I thank you very, very much.

Reviewer: jamies_lady Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/17/2007 - 05:17 pm Title: Chapter 30~ Crimes of the Heart

really enjoyed the update
worried about the inspector, he's going to be trouble.poor buffy, Spike had better sort himself out soon or he's going to really upset her. glad Dawn is on her way

Author's Response: Things should start to get a little more interesting from now on. Thanks for the nice comment.

Reviewer: JO Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/17/2007 - 03:42 pm Title: Chapter 30~ Crimes of the Heart

I really am enjoying this story but am getting increasing angry at Spike , I hope he becomes riddled with guilt over how he's withdrawing from Buffy just when she needs him the most. I know things have to get worse before they get better, but I don't really see any good reason for his behaviour. Your a wonderful writer and I will read anything you write.

Author's Response: Thank you Jo, I'm glad you're enjoying the story. Spike is dealing with some issues. True love rarely runs smooth. Thanks for the comment.

Reviewer: bobo Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/17/2007 - 03:42 pm Title: Chapter 30~ Crimes of the Heart

poor buffy. Spike you are breaking her heart there, buddy. Go and make it up to her.

they need to talk start things out.

Author's Response: Spike is breaking her heart. It's so sad. Thanks for the comment.

Reviewer: katamaphone Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/02/2007 - 01:55 pm Title: Chapter 29~ Trepidation

I love this story and always look forward to seeing an update. Today was no exception, and I happily read the new chapter......now I'm worried. Worried about Buffy's lagging strength; if it's mystical in origin or physiological or if someone (an enemy) is drugging her............And on the emotional front, my heart ( a very mushy organ) is breaking for her. As always, she has no self-confidence in herself in this area. To see her losing her faith in her relationship with Spike is so sad. That knowledge, of his love for her, no matter what ,has always given her strength in the past......................mean, Aamah, mean ::)). If this was a paperback novel I'd have all the pages bent back and ratty by now from all the going back and forth to all my favourite parts . It's a wonderful story and has everything a good read needs to keep the reader an emotional wreck and on the edge of their seat, until we get to the conclusion ;which I hope is happy ( see previous notation about mushy heart organ).....you wouldn't want to be responsible for damaged heart organs now would you??? (insert grin here) .....Really, it's so good I eagerly await the next installment........................................Kathryn

Author's Response: Dear Ms. Mushy Heart, (Kathryn) I have no intentions of causing you heart failure, rest assured. Thank you so much for the wonderful review. I means so much when folks talk about how the story affects them. See, the thing is...things almost always get worse before they get better, don' they? More coming as soon as I can find a new beta. Myfeetshowit (Sandra) is overwhelmed and stepped away.

Reviewer: jamies_lady Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/02/2007 - 06:38 am Title: Chapter 29~ Trepidation

poor buffy and spike they are even more connected than they thought... looking forward to more. i am really enjoying this story and wish i wrote as well as you do.

Author's Response: Oh my lady, what a lovely thing to say. Thank you very much. Don't you just love them? I know I do. Thank you for commenting.

Reviewer: spikey Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/02/2007 - 02:17 am Title: Chapter 29~ Trepidation

yay, a new chapter. This is one of my favorite spuffy stories.

I'm sad for spike and buffy. please make it better.

Author's Response: Apologies for taking so long. Real Life got in the way. It's slowed down for a minute and that's what gave me the time. Thank you so much for your kind comment.

Reviewer: jenny Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 05/02/2007 - 01:44 am Title: Chapter 29~ Trepidation

poor spike and buffy. The both seem so lost.

love the chapter. more please.

Author's Response: Thank you Jenny. I'm glad you enjoyed. Angst is your thing, huh? Just kidding. I'm in a "squee" mood. I just found out that Goodbye, Mr. Giles was nominated over at Love's Last Glimpse Awards! I'm dancing on the ceiling!.

Reviewer: kw Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/27/2007 - 11:34 pm Title: Chapter 28~ New Horizons ~ Lost Hope

I really like your McGregor character

Author's Response: oh! Thank you.

Reviewer: jenny Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/27/2007 - 05:37 pm Title: Chapter 28~ New Horizons ~ Lost Hope

I really like this story. I wouldn't mind helping Spike with his troubles. Move over Buffy. hehe......

More please.

Author's Response: Ah...the queue is very, very long. It seems everyone wants to sooth Spike's fevered brow. I'm glad you like the story...I'm really enjoying writing it too. Thanks so much for the comment...it means a lot.

You must login (register) to review.