Reviews For Black
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Cate Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/27/2008 - 12:06 pm Title: The Downward Spiral

I hate Spike. I hate him so much in this chapter. The funny thing is I rarely ever hate anyone, but this is just evil in its own discrepancies-- no remorse, no emapthy--- hollow. I can't even flick the recommendation to "liked it" even though I absolutely love this story, and will continue to the finish... it's just... I'm pissed!

Reviewer: Verda Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 09/01/2007 - 07:27 am Title: The Downward Spiral

Gotcha, Willy's. Not seeing any redemption here just yet. You've made him about as cold as a human being could be. Glad I've got a few more chapters to go. How is he going to feel about Faith now? She's being about as cruel as he is. this should be interesting to see. You did a great job with writing this.

Author's Response: Not yet, no. The redemption, at first, will be interwoven in the plot, and finally Spike will see the light and he will strive to redeem himself. He hates Faith, just an fyi.

Reviewer: Jaime Bee Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 09/01/2007 - 07:15 am Title: The Downward Spiral

No Remorse? He may feel Vindicated but I can't see him not feeling bad for that.

Author's Response: I'm going remorseless, unfeeling thing. What Buffy thought Spike was in season five and six.

Reviewer: Ariadne Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/25/2007 - 07:00 pm Title: The Downward Spiral

I wonder who is coming?

Author's Response: >_> Someone... an unexpected friend.

Reviewer: squawks Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/28/2007 - 11:00 am Title: The Downward Spiral

I just read through the reviews of this chapter and I have to say I really laughed my head off - boy do some people get fired up! almost to being ridiculous...

anyway, I just thought I'd leave a review now cos its been a while since an update and i always find that new reviews when I'm struggling with the next chapter help, so just so you know there are still readers really liking this fic! I reread the whole thing again today, and its kinda intense all at once but at the same time I can sort of fool myself that I'm doing something educational cos its one of the most intelligent fics out there. At least, thats my excuse.
Anyway, hope you're still updating it and can't wait to see more! I know how it is though with being insanely busy at times so take your time too!

Author's Response: Best. Review. Evar. I'll take the "most intelligent fic" comment and worship it as much as I do SMG (and you'd be surprised how far I go with that, especially with my vast collection of pictures and the danc-- err, nevermind). Seriously. Awesome motivation right there. You can't buy that in stores or on amazon or even ebay (and ebay has everything!). Thank you so much squawks! I'll be rambling in my head about my fic being "intelligent" for weeks (and that was not sarcasm, even though it kinda sounds that way, it's not).

Reviewer: oooooooooooooo Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 03/09/2007 - 04:50 pm Title: The Downward Spiral

oh,and this is a guy who is writing this story. what a shame

Author's Response: That's like reverse discrimination: just because I'm a guy I have to write women as bad people?

Reviewer: ooooooooo Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 03/09/2007 - 04:48 pm Title: The Downward Spiral

Nina, it is more like people have a obession with making Buffy the one in their relationship. That is what I don't like. it is like men are evil and women are not.

buffy always has excuse for being awful. like coming from a horrible home life, being abuse, so on.

while spike is just a jerk for the hell of it.

the author so damage this story. big time

a big fat two thumbs down.

Author's Response: Again, nobody is forcing you to read this story. If you need to have Buffy as the villain in a story, just go write one. Please don't troll, though.

Reviewer: dawn Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/09/2007 - 02:52 pm Title: The Downward Spiral

oh no..wt hs he done...

Author's Response: Something very bad. :(

Reviewer: spuffyz_3rd Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/09/2007 - 05:55 am Title: The Downward Spiral

Wow, Spike is REALLY messed up. He's almost bordering on sociopath, with the way he's completely discarded the ties between right and wrong. This is fabulous writing, I'm well and truly addicted. I have absolutely no idea how you're going to change Spike's current outlook and lack of emotion, how he's going to come to love Buffy, but I can't wait to find out. Please update soon!

Author's Response: Thank you so much! Comments like these really invigorate me and get me churning out chapters. You completely got what I wanted to convey with Spike, and I think you'll be pleased with how things turn out in the end. The end, as you may already know, is still a ways away, as I need to dig Spike out of his grave first before we can even address Spuffy. Thanks for the motivation. :)

Reviewer: ~Eris~ Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/09/2007 - 02:47 am Title: The Downward Spiral

I'm really enjoying this story! Glad to see an update. I wonder how Spike will fix this one? ;-)

Author's Response: Thank you for enjoying! :D Spike will fix everything, just give him time. ;)

Reviewer: annabanana Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/09/2007 - 02:08 am Title: The Downward Spiral

....I'm glad to see you're back, was starting to worry if you were ok....I'm not able to review right now, I need another day to separate my thoughts. If I were to review Spike's behaviour in lieu of it being International Woman's Day and having spent the day at the University's rallies it wouldn't be fair.....that said, I'd certainly classify this chapter's Spike as a monster, not the man Whedon's Spike so often wished Buffy would see him as.

Author's Response: Hopefully I won't have to worry you anymore as soon I'll have an easier class schedule and thus be able to mutilate this story a little more. ;) Spike's most definitely a monster, yes, I think he even recognizes that now, at least partially. I look forward to a full review. ;)

Reviewer: ooooooooooooooo Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 03/08/2007 - 02:30 pm Title: The Downward Spiral

nina, why don't you mind you own business. This story was suppose to be about how Buffy and the others made fun of spike. how the woman he loves made fun of him. not about how spike is a jerk and treats people like dirt.

I say how i feel. if you don't like it then don't read the reviews, nina.

I did like the story. and I gave it a chance for it to get better. this is a spuffy site. I don't see how spuffy is going to happen

Author's Response: It started as that, yes, but quickly evolved (or devolved if that's what you think) like most stories do. You certainly don't need to keep repeating your feelings for the same chapter over and over again, though. I understand what you're saying and where you're coming from.

Reviewer: Nina Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/08/2007 - 07:57 am Title: The Downward Spiral

Oooooooo - you just don't get it. Don't do to this fic what you've done to so many and start a war of reviews - no one wants to hear what you have to say anymore. Obviously you have some obsession with not wanting Spike to be a bad guy, but read the story - Buffy isn't perfect like you said at all.

TestaALT - don't respond to any of ooooooo's comments, they're just there to be inflammatry and annoying. They just want you to get into an argument and cause problems like he/she's done with so many other fics.

By the way, love the fic. Sorry if you were already onto the ignoring stage.

Author's Response: I know; I've seen other fics that ooooo has left in ashes. I much prefer to respond to what ooooo has to say, though, while at the same time not give into the blatant trolling and flaming. Thanks for this, though; it's reassuring to know that no one takes anything s/he has to say with any grain of salt. And, most important of all, thanks for reading! :D

Reviewer: ooooooooooooo Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 03/08/2007 - 05:03 am Title: The Downward Spiral

Fucking Spike hater. That is what you are.

Buffy is so perfect. Doesn't do anything wrong.


this story sucks big ones. Although, I did like it. until all you want is to have Spike look bad over and over again. while buffy is the most perfect thing to ever walk the earth.

Author's Response: Buffy is so far from being perfect it's not even funny. You don't have to read the story if you don't want to.

Reviewer: scaryscouse Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 11:28 pm Title: The Downward Spiral

I don't get it, why is he so unfeeling & downright nasty. I can't imagine that she will ever forgive him or them ever getting together, there is too much hate

Author's Response: You're 100% right: too much hate. Spike will need to see the problem, look for solutions to the problem, and finally set out to solve the problem. Once this happens, and with a little help from the story with some rescuing and other secrets revealed, it will be completely plausible to see the both of them together. I got it all worked out in my head, trust me. ;) Thanks for commenting!

Reviewer: J Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 04:38 pm Title: The Downward Spiral

Glad to see an update! Very emotional chapter, and very well written. Kind of surprised that Spike doesn't feel any sympathy for what he's done. But kind of not surprising? Does that make sense? Anyway, looking very forward for the next chapter!

Author's Response: Completely makes sense; I've kind of written it that hot-cold way, so you don't really know if Spike loves Buffy or not. Sometimes it looks like he does and other times it looks like he doesn't at all. Don't worry, though; he'll make the right choice later in the story. Thanks for the feedback! :D

Reviewer: squawks Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 11:25 am Title: The Downward Spiral

hmmmm, definitely a lot to think about. its kind of weird for me to like this story cos I'm usually such fluff lover all the way, with bits of angst here and there to make it interesting. But this is something even more than angst, which is why I don't quite understand why I love it but I do...so, well, thats my point. I love it. Hope you update soon.

Also, don't think I've said it yet - I love your style of writing. I'm always amazed at the amount of fics that come out with shocking grammar/paragraph configuration/etc...but yours is always written beautifully, with great language as well. Lots of big words - obviously you listen in school! or read heaps. Either way, great writing. Hope you plan to write more after this fic.

Author's Response: Thank you so much squawks! :D Writing style comments are some of the greatest, most cherished reviews I get, so thanks! :) I guess you pretty much nailed this fic dead on the head with "something even more than angst," kind of snowballed into that one, though, didn't really intend it. And yes, I do actually plan on writing a bit more after this fic; I have a few ideas that might be, at the very least, a little more popular and less offensive to the Spuffy public, maybe even easier to write about. Thanks again! :D

Reviewer: ooooooooooooo Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 07:00 am Title: The Downward Spiral

Enough of this let us make spike bad and feel sorryfor Buffy. I actually liked this story. but you are making impossible to like spike and want him to be with her.

We get it, Spike is bad and jerk and rule. While buffy hasn't done anything wrong in her life

Author's Response: >_< That's a small part of it, yes. But I also want Spike to strive to be a better man through this, solve his character flaws. You're not suppose to like Spike right now, nor are you suppose to disregard all the bad things Buffy did before this fic began (which has been referenced several times). Thanks for commenting.

Reviewer: Angi Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 06:14 am Title: The Downward Spiral

Well, if he still feels that way, this story is categorized spuffy why? Who wants her to still end up with him now? You made it so that they can´t come back from it. It´s a pity, I actually liked this story. But what you said about Spike, that he STILL feels that he had the right to do all this to her, and that it wasn´t wrong, that just kills it for me. It´s too much. The scale has sunken down too low on his side, the things he knew and did to her anyway weigh way more than what she ever did to him.

Author's Response: No, no, no, I said that he still felt that way but also that it was the sickest, most twisted feeling he ever felt in his life. In Spike's thoughts he also says "I'm sick" and that he feels horrible for not feeling any remorse or emotion whatsoever. He knows that something is wrong with him, and a big part of this story is Spike realizing what's wrong with him, trying to solve the problem, and finally becoming a man of worth. I'm not saying that he's instantly gonna try to be "better" (this is Spike, after all :) but he'll be introspective down the road and realize his major character flaws, set out to fix them, and along the way help Buffy. Redemption theme, like Crime and Punishment, with a curable hamartia tagged in. This is still and will always be Spuffy, but the angsty Spuffy with hopefully good gritty realism. Lowpoint of the story, and I _know_, most of the story has been "lowpoints." Thanks for the feedback.

Reviewer: jen Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 06:00 am Title: The Downward Spiral

Can we PLEASE hope it's Giles?! Happy to see the update.

Author's Response: Actually I'm reserving Giles for a bit later. ^_^

Reviewer: PhotographyNut Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 04:14 am Title: The Downward Spiral

Spike is a very sick puppy. Nobody deserves what he just did to Buffy. Can't wait to read more!

Author's Response: I wholeheartedly agree with your assertion. I think Spike does, too. Thanks for the feedback; you always do a great job showing me what you think. :)

Reviewer: effection Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 03:28 am Title: The Downward Spiral

God. Spike and his fucking vendetta. I know people like him and it just pisses me off that they think they have the right to want some sick kind of revenge just because so and so made fun of them back in the day. I expected Spike to get OVER it and come out better, not worse. He's just... gah. He makes me so frustrated.

Author's Response: It's the end of the rope as far as that, though. Those last lines were meant to be introspective; Spike is thinking about what he did and how horrible it was. This sets up, as you stated, Spike getting "over it" and really ending the hate. But, yeah, end of the line for that; he might relapse a little, but the last part was meant for him to look at himself and see how bad he is and really begin the story of striving to be a better person. Thanks for commenting, always appreciated! :D

Reviewer: rosie Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 03:25 am Title: The Downward Spiral

can't wait to see what happens next!!!!!!!!! :D

Author's Response: Thank you. :)

Reviewer: anon Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 01:42 am Title: The Downward Spiral

an update - thank you. it was good, dont know how much of the evil spike i cant take, i'm sure it wasn't just buffy who was mean to him but he's really being a bastard to her and what she did was the past hes ruining the now. Spike doesn't even feel bad. how much do you want us to hate him? sorry about the rant just buffy life really suck.

Author's Response: Yes, he is being a bastard. He's a bad person right now. He'll realize that in the next few chapters and try to be a better person through this event (probably fail, though, I mean, this is Spike we're talking about). And we'll also find out later that things aren't as they seem, and they may help Spike's case, also. Thanks for commenting.

Reviewer: Dana Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 03/07/2007 - 01:39 am Title: The Downward Spiral

I cant believe he doesn't even feel guilty for hurting her!

Author's Response: Me tooooooooo. :( He's such a horrible person. He'll start to realize this, though, and set out to be better. Thanks for always commenting! :)

You must login (register) to review.