Reviews For Something True
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Kat Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/23/2009 - 10:04 pm Title: Meet The Family

I love the story line. As a suggestion, don't leave out the emotions. When Spike tells her that her mom has a brain tumor or when she tells him he's the father, it's missing the emotional side. He would be so happy or angry and Buffy would be devastated about her mother. Otherwise it's great!

Author's Response: Thanks. I'm going to take your advice to heed in future chapters. If you see any problems in future chapters, don't be afraid to let me know.

Reviewer: Amaya Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/23/2009 - 03:41 pm Title: Meet The Family

Hello. I like this story very much, so please keep writing. Bye.

Author's Response: Thank you. If you have any ideas for future chapters, please let me know.

Reviewer: cordykitten Signed [Report This]
Date: 08/23/2009 - 10:25 am Title: Meet The Family

Regarding the last chapter - Five years are a long time to go 'cold turkey' to stop being the slayer.
I have trouble to imagine Buffy to quit like that (and never visiting Joyce or showing her mother - or her sister - her daughter) but I will read on to see how it ends. ~

So Buffy told Spike now. And Spike said nothing about that Buffy ran, hiding the fact he was a father from him? She got 'off the hook' way too easy for what she did (just my opinion). Good thing that Spike believes her that he is the father.

Dawn and Connor, huh?




Regarding the beta: If you have a good Beta (means who isn't only checking for grammar) you'll find a help there with the story, looking out for plot holes etc. too. To quote an entry where it is said better:
What the hell is a beta for, anyways? Some would say proofreader, some would say idea-bouncer, some as a check and balance to ensure proper characterization, and some would say collaboration. I would say that the ideal beta is a combination of all of these.
If you interested to read the whole entry, it's here. Another one is here

Author's Response: Thanks for the advice. Don't worry, there's going to be a slight blow up between Spike and Buffy in a future chapter, but I'm not all that good at angst. Tried it before and it ended up turning to fluff.

Reviewer: jen Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/23/2009 - 05:49 am Title: Meet The Family

I really like your story and where it's going to go! :)

Author's Response: Thanks. I had a vision of where it was going, but changed my mind, so now I'm working on that vision.

Reviewer: PhotographyNut Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/23/2009 - 02:57 am Title: Meet The Family

Just found this fic and love it! Looking forward to more!

Author's Response: Thank you.

Reviewer: v4viper Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/23/2009 - 02:41 am Title: Meet The Family

your doing fine without a beta relax story is getting more and more interesting I do feel that
spike took the news of fatherhood too easily more please

Author's Response: Thank you. That is just a cover. Things will blow up between the pair soon.

Reviewer: melissa Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/23/2009 - 01:30 am Title: Meet The Family

yay!!!!! you updated this you made my day since im sick with a bad cold, cant wait for my updates

Author's Response: Thank you. You made my day with your review.

Reviewer: Jenn Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/22/2009 - 11:55 pm Title: Meet The Family

I like the idea of this story but i was somewhat cofused with the story line. Where Buffy starts crying in the living room then all of a sudden she's in bed with Spike. I thought his reaction would be a little more harsher being that she kept his child away from him for five years thats a really long time.

Author's Response: Don't worry, there's going to be a blow out between Buffy and Spike soon. Asking Spike to stay with her was more of a comfort thing for Buffy than anything else.

Reviewer: All4Spike Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/16/2009 - 10:55 am Title: Welcome To Sunnydale

I love the premise of this fic, but as others have already pointed out I'm finding the narrative very sketchy, I feel you haven't gone into nearly enough detail. i'm also upset with Buffy for staying away for so long. Who has been doing the slaying? Who has dealt with Adam & Glory?
I'll keep reading to find out what's going on, and to see Spike's reaction when he sees Katie-Beth.
Oh, just a technical point - it looks as if you chose to express Buffy's thoughts in pointy brackets. The compuer sees these as HTML tags and as the tags aren't true HTML the thoughts are all missing. I think we really need to follow her thoughts as a means to find out what's going on so I suggest you try using italics or bold, or curly brackets instead.

Author's Response: Thanks for the advice about the HTML. I was posting late at night and I was just a tad sleepy as I'd had an exam resit earlier in the day and just missed that mistake. This story went AU after Something Blue, so Adam hadn't been mentioned then and as Dawn is just a normal human who had lived in LA up to this point, there was no need for Glory, But, please note, I have explainedsome of this later on and will do in future chapters that I write.

Reviewer: cordykitten Signed [Report This]
Date: 08/15/2009 - 11:43 am Title: Welcome To Sunnydale

Buffy was gone for five years? That's five years she stole her baby girl the father's baby = time that Spike had could have spend with the daughter he never knew now. Not sure how I would take this secret if it was my daughter. That's very long especially for when a child is young.

And it sounds as if Buffy doesn't work as a slayer any longer? So what did she do instead.

Author's Response: I know that five years is a long time, as many other reviewers have commented on this. I do address this slightly in chapters I have already written, but it also gives me an idea for future chapters. As for what Buffy done other than slaying, she was busy raising Katie-Beth and becoming an artist.

Reviewer: Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/15/2009 - 05:33 am Title: Welcome To Sunnydale

okay, i'm confused, not sure how i feel about this fiction yet, but i wasn't expecting for it to be five years later. i'm disappointed in buffy, i get that she wants to keep her daughter safe, but i don't understand why she would have been away for that long, not even telling anyone where she was. and if spike is somewhat of a friend here, at least he seems like it, looking after her mom and all, how could buffy not even tell him that he's the father? so, yeah, i'm a little disappointed so far. she doesn't seem like she wants him in her life or her daughter's, i may give one more chapter a chance, but it's too soon to tell if i'll continue to read this.

Author's Response: Thanks for your review. I will certainly think about the issues you've raised and possibly address then in future chapters.

Reviewer: Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/15/2009 - 05:04 am Title: Welcome To Sunnydale

Looking forward to Spike and Buffy's meeting, and introducing Katie-Beth to Spike. I love the little hints you've put in the chapter, like Buffy's art Warm Blue Eyes. I wonder if she'll draw or paint or make something that Spike will see?

Thank you for updating so quickly.

Author's Response: Thanks, I think I mention the artwork later on, but I'm not sure. If I haven't it will deffinately come up in a future chapter I haven't written yet.

Reviewer: v4viper Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/15/2009 - 03:18 am Title: Welcome To Sunnydale

Woohoo cant wait for the great meeting

Author's Response: Thank you for the review. I know this fic is a little sketchy, so I don't mind if you tell me where you think I need to make some changes.

Reviewer: a Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/15/2009 - 02:43 am Title: Prologue

This is an interesting set-up, but I wish it were fleshed out more. It seems more like a list or an outline than a story in places, because it doesn't explain why things are happening.

For example, why does Buffy want Dawn to come stay with Joyce? To keep Joyce company? Why does the gang not know anything about Dawn?

Why is Buffy fleeing to L.A. and then Boston? Is it to escape slaying? Or to keep Spike from finding out he's the father of her baby? Why couldn't she just say it was Parker's or another one night stand's, if that's the worry?

Why would Spike agree to move into Joyce's basement? Even if he is fond of her, what's in it for him?

It seems like you have a story to tell, here, and it could be an interesting one. I hope you will slow down the narrative pace, take the time to let your readers into the characters' heads or at least see more of their conversations, so that their actions make sense.

Author's Response: This, although my second post, is my first fic ever writtten so any tips on it is gladly accepted. I will be addressing some of the issues you have mentioned in future chapters and if I dhaven't addressed them in chapters I have already written I will begin to address them when type up more of this fic.

Reviewer: DK Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/15/2009 - 02:32 am Title: Prologue

Great start and a very good idea for the plot. Thanks for sharing/

Author's Response: Thank you for the review. If you do find anything that is an issue for you, don't be afraid to let me know.

Reviewer: Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/14/2009 - 07:58 pm Title: Prologue

I like the idea of your plot, though I don't know why Buffy's sister would be living with their father in L.A. and would suddenly move in with Joyce. This chapter seems to be skipping over showing the feelings and emotions that should be there, but I think that's just because you want to hurry with the set up so you can start the real story. Will the fact that Buffy had the possibility of a child and that Angelus forced her to miscarry come up again? It seemed important.

I look forward to seeing how your plot moves forward, though I would suggest slowing down enough to *show* the emotions Buffy must be going through.

Author's Response: Normally I would keep my posts for Fridays, but seeing as there is a great response to Something True, I am going to post the next chapter as soon as I've finished answering my reviews. Sorry for the confusion, the next chapter zooms forward five years, but then slows down. I will take note of your suggestions and possibly use them in future chapters.

Reviewer: iris Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/14/2009 - 07:19 pm Title: Prologue

Buffy having Spike's baby is , of course, the story we all want. The trick is not waiting forever between chapters. There have been some great stories on this site, but you can totally lose the momentum and the enjoyment when you have to keep starting at the beginning over and over. Some of the best writers haven't added for months -VERY FRUSTRATING! Thanks for listening - I didn't mean to complain!




Author's Response: Normally I would keep my posts for Fridays, but seeing as there is a great response to Something True, I am going to post the next chapter as soon as I've finished answering my reviews. So, after this I will try and keep my posts for Fridays.

Reviewer: cordykitten Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/14/2009 - 04:50 pm Title: Prologue

Ah I wasn't sure first who was the father of the baby, Angel of Spike but it were both, first Angel (but Buffy lost the baby) and then Spike (I'd thought first Buffy was still pregnant by Angel).
Not sure where you'll take it now that Buffy is gone now, getting her child alone. But I'll definitely check out the next chapters to find out more.

Author's Response: Normally I would keep my posts for Fridays, but seeing as there is a great response to Something True, I am going to post the next chapter as soon as I've finished answering my reviews. Sorry if I confused you slightly.

Reviewer: v4viper Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/14/2009 - 04:20 pm Title: Prologue

Good beginning you got the background done now on with the story which looks to be very interesting more please

Author's Response: Normally I would keep my posts for Fridays, but seeing as there is a great response to Something True, I am going to post the next chapter as soon as I've finished answering my reviews.

Reviewer: Bridget Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/14/2009 - 04:14 pm Title: Prologue

Interesting story so far. Please update.

Author's Response: Normally I would keep my posts for Fridays, but seeing as there is a great response to Something True, I am going to post the next chapter as soon as I've finished answering my reviews.

You must login (register) to review.