You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Fran Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 02:40 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

I love your Buffy and her note made me smile. Spike, on the other hand, I want to smack. He is being a wanker and I hope he snaps out of it soon before he really does lose Buffy. I would worry if there wasn't any angst because that would mean the story was wrapping up and that is the last thing I want.

Reviewer: Shauna Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 02:36 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

Also de-lurking to comment...

I've really enjoyed this story, and I thought this chapter was great. I really hope this weekend in Sunnydale really does give Joyce and Buffy the chance to mend fences, so that she has someone to provide emotional support when things hit the fan with Spike (and at some point they will if he's being driven to the bottle like that, though I do kind of get why he's doing it). I loved Buffy's letter (very cute) and the interaction with the always-insightful Oz. Great work, and I can't wait to see what happens next.

Reviewer: Sara Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 01:16 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

This story has way too much angst. Why can't you read my mind and write exactly like I want it.

Reviewer: C C Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 01:15 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

I think I will crawl out of lurkdom as well.

I am so sorry people are giving you such a hard time. Instead of thanking you for your time and energy they are asking you to change your story. So sorry about that.

I for one absolutely love this story and it's direction. I also love the angst and don't think there is too much at all. You are writing the story wonderfully. Hopefully those reviewers won't get you down too much!

Reviewer: Nicole S. Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 01:07 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

Alright, after reading your author's note I was inspired to I'm crawl out of lurkerdom for the first time. I just had to tell you how much I'm enjoying this story. Personally, I love some angst. It makes the story more realistic for me. Also, I have really enjoyed Buffy's journey in this story and I can't wait to see where my favorite couple ends up.

I've read all of your stories and after reading your note today I just wanted to let you know how much I've loved all of them. Thank you so much for all your time and effort and the entertainment you've given me.

Reviewer: sarah g Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 12:49 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

nooooo, why spike. i cant believe spike went to drink after his drinking gave her reason to leave and doubt their relationship. i love this story and am so happy u updated. i really hope that wen she comes back and they talk things through. im glad that oz talked to spike and i really wish that he would listen to his insticts not desires. also i hope that wen buffy comes back that she doesnt leave him if/wen she finds out he'd been drinking and that they talked through their problems. please update as soon as u can, i cant wait to read more. thanx

Reviewer: Angie Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 12:46 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

More please!

Reviewer: jeanie Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 12:16 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

what are we going to do with spike? i guess just love him till he gets a clue. ignore the people who complain abaout the angst, let them write their own stories, if they can. i like all of your stories just the way they are. i do not know of any couple that is happy 24/7, do you? angst is in our everyday lives. keep up the good work just like you want

Reviewer: PhotographyNut Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/12/2006 - 12:14 am Title: Chapter Forty-One

Spike's in big trouble now if he feels he needs a drink. What if Buffy came back unexpectedly?? Their relationship would be in a bigger mess! When did Spike become such a jerk?? Great chapter, though. Love this fic!

Reviewer: secretguest Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 11:51 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

*SCREAMING IN FRUSTATION* SPIKE!!!!!!!!! Stupid boy! Sigh...when will he learn that his stupid drinking isn't helping him or the situation?!?!?!?! That's part of the reason she's not happy with him! Gosh...I just feel like kicking his ass myself!!! I really do hope this doesn't cause even more problems. I'm starting to wonder if he should go to an AA meeting or something.

Great chapter! I don't mind the angst if there's happiness towards the end at all. In fact, I like it that way. To me, it makes the relationship more special. It's more real life. So I think you should keep it up! It's a great fic! Ignore those who don't like it! just do what you feel is right! I think you're doing a wonderful job!

Update soon please! I can't wait to see the outcome of his drinking and everything else!

Reviewer: Sara M Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 11:37 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

Makes me sad to see Spike trying to solve his problems with a bottle. Buffy doesn't help much with the running away. Poor kids! You gave far to many warnings about this story, I mean it almost put me off from reading it, but I did and it simply lovely. Keep up the great work :)

Reviewer: teasha Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 11:30 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

so sad spike is an alcoholic. well enjoying buffy's point of view and hoping that spike uses this time away to think more than drink

Reviewer: annefan Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 11:12 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

Well Addie, you took the liberty to add an author's note before the new chapter so it seems only fair that a reader can ass a reader's note as well. I respect you and your work, you're a fantastic writter, the fact that you've already got more than 1000 review for this proves it. But please understand that you cant expect people to only review when they have positive things to say and just "shut up" when they want to say someting else. Readers have the right to review when they like it AND when they dont like it. And no, it's not about the angst. You're the one who keeps bringing this subject back :) I think I was quite courteous in my comments though. I said I was finding this part too dark? i could have easily find something else to say like "it sucked" (and no, it didnt suck! it was just an example).
I wont stop reading your fic, I enjoy it so far and there's not reason for me to stop reading it. Just think I'll wait for a few chapters to be posted and see what's happening with Buffy's and Spike's relationship ;)

Author's Response: I bring it up because it's brought up by the readers. Look, I'll be blunt--you don't know what kind of reviews I get on the whole or the conversations I've had with readers. I left that note for a reason, and I asked for a courtesy which you have not afforded me. Furthermore, from your responses, you clearly don't even understand what I'm trying to say. I've never said "shut up." I've asked SPECIFICALLY for people not to tell me this story has too much angst. That's not too much to ask. You chose to turn right around, ignore what I asked people to please do as a personal favor.

If you have anything more to say about me personally, please email me. The review forum is not the place to critique me as a person.

Reviewer: txjmfan Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 11:02 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

Well, Buffy's letter relieved a little of the angst of the situation. I know people do stupid things when they're in a bad place and are laning a little too heavily on a crutch. Crutches are okay, but when you start rationalizing a way to still use them, even when you don't need them as much, then it's an addiction. Hope their talk touches on that. Great chapter.

Reviewer: Sara M Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:55 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

Love the story, sorry you got negative criticism for having angst in your clearly marked angsty story. I never understand that kind of review. I know people want things to happen a certain way in a story and get vested in their point of view, but really it's not helpful if you're trying to criticize the author on those points. A note saying you'd be thrilled if X happened is fine, as long as it's understood that the author is in no way obligated to do X. I like seeing people's ideas on what I'm writing and what they think might happen next, it helps me see if I'm getting my story across if a lot of people are reviewing that they don't get it or do get it. When a story is very long - like this one - sometimes people get impatient for whatever their secret hope for the story is and I can understand that too if they are not beating me up about it. I just got a review for my story on another site where someone complained one third of the way in that she 'smelled redemption and it stinks'. She still has about 100000 words to get caught up to the current chapter so I thought she could at least have read it to see if it's going there or not before griping, and also she's off base in her assumption. To complain that you 'know' what an author is going to write and then complain about your assumption seems very weird and rude to me. Oh well. I just wanted to support your story and your viewpoint, and put my two cents into the 'if it's labeled then read the label and stop complaining about it' theme. It's like reading a story that you know is spuffy and then complaining because Spike and Buffy get together in it or because it's 'been done before'. I don't know, maybe my next story will pair Buffy off with a Mohra demon and make it all fluffy. I'm pretty sure that's not done yet. Good work Addie, and I love this story as I love all your stories. You rock.

Reviewer: annefan Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:50 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

So, from now on, as soon as a review doesnt sound positive, you're going to answer "I dont need a rant or a flame" juste because for once people dont agree 100% with your point of view ? It may sound rude but it's a little childlish. We all are entitled to have our own opinion. Yes it is your story and of course you can write whatever you want, but when you choose to post it here and you expect people to send you feedbacks, it's normal that some reviews are "negative". I mentioned in my last review that I thought there was too much angst... in my opinion! I know you warned us about it and frenkly that's what I love the most in your fic. However, between Joyce's surgery and Spike jealousy, I think there was too much angst at the same time. It was not my way to say "I didnt like this chapter" because it was a good part but honestly you cant expect people to be ectasic about this fic all the time. I'm happy to see that I was not the only to think that about the last chapter though.
As for this one, I feel the same as for the previous one. It was well written but it's getting too dark for me (and yes, I know you mentioned "angsty" several times). I think I'm going to stop the reading for a while, I'll check in two weeks or so to see where it's going :)
Thanks for sharing this and the quick update. Belive it or not, but I REALLY enjoy your story. I may have offended you with my comments and please believe me when I say it's not my intention but I dont think it's fair for you to expect only positive reviews all the time.

P.S : sorry for my english ;)

Author's Response: It was not just you. It was several people, and yes, it bothered me.

If you don't want to read it, fine, don't. But I ASKED you not to lay into me about, and you just did. Can you please just respect me and not go off on me about the angst or me asking people to respect me enough not to tell me they don't like it? I KNOW some people don't like it, but telling me makes no difference. Asking people to respect me there is not childish--it's asking for some courtesy, which you apparently don't have.


Author's Response: I have also, by the way, never said all reviews must be positive or that I will respond to all negative reviews. I've said that I don't want complaints about the angst because I'm sick of hearing it and I'm not changing my story and I've said that I reserve the right to respond to any review and I don't want to be chided for it.

Some people enjoy angst, and I'm writing this story for them. Even if that audience is small, it's still my audience, and I'm going to write this story to the best of my ability. If you don't like that sort of story, be an adult and politely stop reading. I don't feel this story deserve heaps of complaints, especially about something clearly marked and addressed in notes. You're complaining about the genre of the story, and that's just silly. Would you read a humor story and then complain to the author about it being too funny?

Reviewer: Laura Liz Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:38 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

well...at least he's drinking at home, and not going out to do something completely stupid. but maybe a phone call would be nice.... ;)

Reviewer: Debbie Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:24 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

i think it is sad that you feel the need to add your note about the angst, that has always been their MO. Anyway it is evident that Spike has a problem, but it is always darkest before the dawn, but the dawn will come. And isn't that life? Nothing ever runs smoothly, if it did we wouldn't appreciate the good times. Great chapter and thanks

Reviewer: Sandra Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:17 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

Have not long been reading and sorry not to have reviewed before now but after seeing your note wanted to say how great I think you story is. Life is not all roses and things go wrong for people and how they deal with problems is what makes it more interesting. It is also the way people either stay together or fall apart. I dont know why people have to criticise a story when it is so well written - I only read stories as I dont feel capable of writing and although I have not been reading fan fiction long I am astounded at the quality of writing there is and how you are all prepared to give up your free time for this. Please dont be disheartened and I look forward to your next instalment and I promise to try and review more frequently

Reviewer: shelly Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:13 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

excellent chapter i love how your story is progressing

Reviewer: Satindoll Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:06 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

Double oy! You're really laying it on now. I'm scared. I hope nobody gets irreparable hurt here.

Reviewer: SarahandJamesFanatic Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:05 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

good updates to this story

Reviewer: SarahandJamesFanatic Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 10:04 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

good updates to this story

Reviewer: McChick Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 09:51 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

The bottle... again... oh Spike, I have faith that everything will work out eventually! And as for those people who dont like the angst, 1) read the genres 2) read the warnings/author notes 3) suck it up! The angst can make the good endings so much better!!! Loved this chapter, love the story and luv your writing!!!

-Ashley-

Reviewer: Aprillyn Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/11/2006 - 09:50 pm Title: Chapter Forty-One

GAH!! Good Chapter, yes it is angsty but not much more so than alot of peoples real lives so keep up the good work and don't let the bad reviews get you down.

You must login (register) to review.