Spuffy with Original Characters Mark/Johnny

Hi um so yeah i remember reading this story once and im pretty sure it had a pairing of Johnny/Tara and Mark/Willow with spuffy of course. i just remember that they was this totally weird moment when willow/buffy and their significant others had to go to a powerful witch for protection and that witch was tara and then there was akwardness bc Willow thought Tara was only gay but clearly she was living/in love with a man Johnny who i want to say had a purple mohak? So that is about all i can remember. If you can help at all thanks. I know that Jypzrose used those original characters some but i couldnt find what i was looking for on her site. Hoping someone else has read this!

i think it's return to me

It is definitely Return to Me. I just re-read it the other day. It should be on her site!

Could it be PHANTOM WHISPERS by Jypz (Jypzrose). She used Johny and Mark also in her Speedway fic. Mark usually have weird hair color.

http://web.archive.org/web/20031030051345/www.spuffyfantasy.com/

I thought about Jypzroze too. Phantom Whispers Prologue-Ch3 Chapter 4-6 Chapter 7-9 Chapter 10-12 Chapter 13-15 Chapter 16-18 Chapter 19-21 Chapter 22-Epilogue (Completed 12/22/03)
AU, everybody human. Spike, Mark, and Johnny head to the small town of Sunnydale California to work on songs for their new album. It should be a nice, quiet place to work, right? Wrong! What they find is a decades old murder and a ghost that haunts their dreams. With the help of three local girls, can they find the murderer before the murderer finds them?
Found at the crypt here or SA. Her site is down for good.

Thank you so much guys! the links are very helpful. Appreciate it!