I have already tried this search and it was unsuccessful before so *crosses fingers* maybe this time I can get different results. I have already read I'd Lie by Pixicorn, tear drops on my guitar by Tammy, and a few others whose titles I can't recall *sigh*. Please if you know of one post it!

There is another 'Teardrops on My Guitar.'

Teardrops On My Guitar by SpuffyGirl729

Buffy Summers and William 'Spike' Bradley have been best friends for the past four years. Spike thinks of Buffy as a little sister but Buffy has been in love with him since the moment she saw him. How will she handle it when she finally decides to tell him how she feels and he has found someone else?