I remember that Buffy made a wish with a vengeance demon and had a long list about how she wanted her human Spike. She even had a rule he couldn't explain some kind of soccer play and she was tricked because she wished him out of love with her for a pizza, I believe. He keeps his strength and he goes to Tara or Anya for help. At the end Warren is about to shoot her and Spike jumps out the window to save her. Spuffy ending, I can't remember if Spike stayed human. I really hope someone out there can help me, thanks

It sounds like "It's Got To Be Perfect" by Speaker To Customers. According to his web sight he's taken most of his BTVS down.

Thank you so much, now I have to just find a copy of it

Hi

You can find all of Speaker To Customers fics on his website if you go via The Way Back Machine ( web.archive.org)

"It's Got To Be Perfect" is there.

Speaker To Customers fics

I tried to post the address as an actual link with the link button, but it didn't work.