Reviews For Silently Broken
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: secretguest Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/01/2006 - 06:23 pm Title: Chapter 37

I wonder how their meeting will go. Update soon please!

Reviewer: Jenn Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/01/2006 - 05:54 pm Title: Chapter 37

arrggghhhh what an evil place to leave us!!! More more more I love this story!

Reviewer: sarah g Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/01/2006 - 05:29 pm Title: Chapter 37

NOOOO!!!! I WANT TO READ WAT HAPPENS NEXT!!! i love this story so much and am so happy u updated. i cant believe that giles said all that about spike and im so glad that joyce stuck up for him and wants him and buffy to work things out. i really hope that buffys glad to see him and that they talk and work their problems between them out. also i hope that spike doesnt let buffy push him away and that buffy sees that theyre meant to be together. please update as soon as u can, i CANT wait to read the next chapter and see wat happens between buffy and spike. thanx

Reviewer: Madame Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/01/2006 - 05:25 pm Title: Chapter 37

I really like the interaction between Spike and Giles in this chapter. It’s great! Can't wait for more.

Reviewer: cordykitten Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/01/2006 - 05:02 pm Title: Chapter 37

Giles was very protective.. of Buffy or of William? He is trying to protect Buffy though. ~ Good that Joyce didn't tell Giles everything Buffy told her. Buffy has to tell Giles herself or tell Joyce she can tell Giles (me thinks). And William is there now. I wonder what Buffy will say now. ~ Till next chapter!

Reviewer: sarah g Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/01/2006 - 01:32 am Title: Chapter 36

OMG!!!! i cant believe that buffy told joyce and i really hope that wen william gets there that she doesnt judge him and isnt mean to him. i LOVE this story so much and am so happy u updated. i really hope that buffy and william talk things through and that they work it out. also i hope that giles and joyce dont try to stop william and buffy being together and that everything works out. please update as soon as u can, i cant wait to read the next chapter and see wat happens. thanx

Reviewer: Im_bloody_English Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/01/2006 - 12:48 am Title: Chapter 36

Waiting on the next chappy for Spike to show up Very deep and intense this chappy was, great job hon.

Reviewer: Im_bloody_English Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/01/2006 - 12:47 am Title: Chapter 36

Waiting on the next chappy for Spike to show up Very deep and intense this chappy was, great job hon.

Reviewer: blondiebear Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 07:55 pm Title: Chapter 36

loved it. glad buffy got everything out in the open. post soon.

Reviewer: Claudia Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 04:55 pm Title: Chapter 36

Thanks a lot for this great chapter! I'm so happy things are going better for Buffy and I can't wait for the talk with William!

Reviewer: Sara M Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 12:14 pm Title: Prologue and Chapter One

One reviewer said they didn't think Buffy would tell Joyce all of this stuff like that, and in a way I agree that that is a logical thing to think. But I recall my brother a few years ago stayed out late (he was seventeen) and my mom waited up for him to come home which happened at almost three am. He was really drunk and he'd been driving and would have been yelled at except he was really drunk and my mom decided to save the yelling and punishment til next day when he'd understand it better. But my brother was really really loopy with the drink and decided that it would be a good idea to tell my mom everything he did, everything he thought, the whole thing, And when she'd try to get him to go to bed so they could sleep and discuss it fully in the morning he wouldn't do it, he said he needed to get it all out now, while he wanted to say it and just told her EVERYthing. It was funny really and he regretted it the next day. But he'd been loopy and just decided to do a full confessional while loopy. Which is a lot of words to say that the stuff in her system still and the stress of the situation could cause Buffy to suddenly decide to confess things that she wouldn't otherwise even though she might not be so brave under other circumstances. I was sorry Joyce reacted a little more negatively than I would have liked at some points, but I guess she was pretty shocked. If I had a kid who had just tried suicide (and sadly I have one who started at age eleven, long story) I wouldn't have reacted negatively in any way to absolutely anything they told me right afterward, when they were trying so hard to get it out in the open and were looking for understanding and support. So I thought Joyce was a little harsh in places. That's not a criticism, because that's what you wanted Joyce to do so that's just her character and you wrote her the way you wanted her. I was just sorry she did that. As for the hold, I am not aware of any twenty four hour hold in California law, just the 72 hour one. And although I'm dealing with med social work it's mostly with industrial patients and work comp is exempt from HiPPA privacy laws for the most part so that's why I'm not dealing with HIPPA as much as others might so I'll defer to the other posters who are working in general mental health in California for the latest actual practice issues. Like I said, I'm not gonna complain about what you do as long as you don't go on a complete flight of fancy and ignore reality entirely, which you have not at all. I really like your story and I'm following you where you wanna go. It will be interesting to see what happens next -- now that Joyce knows. And will she tell Giles - if I were Buffy I'd prefer to have Joyce tell Giles as at least I wouldn't have to look in the eyes of a man I love like a father and have to tell him all that extremely embarrassing info. Bad enough if he must know, but please let someone else tell it and spare me that is my thinking. Please update soon -- I'm can't wait to see where you go next. Thanks. Mac 1. :-)

Reviewer: Edgehead Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 11:47 am Title: Chapter 36

Yeah...i understand Buffy...and I hope that it will be all good in the end.

Reviewer: Dirktavian Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 04:45 am Title: Chapter 36

Let's hope Joyce doesn't try to OD after hearing all of that about her daughter! ;) OK-- not something really to job about. Buffy really needed to unload all of that baggage. Now maybe Joyce won't be so critical of her, when she sees how really critical she has been on herself.

I didn't read the reviews about all the confidentiality stuff and 24 vs 72 hour holds, since - hey- fiction here. But I actually work for the State of California doing disability evaluations, so I read a LOT of medical records, including mental health treatment notes. When someone is admitted for a suicide attempt, they are first stabilized medically (what Buffy went through in the ER). Then, they are automatically placed on a 72 hour hold for being gravely disabled (danger to self or others). The only way they wouldn't qualify for this hold is if they weren't really homicidal or suicidal (i.e. they said it to get out of going to jail, or some other difficult family situation) and they manage to convince the psychiatrist of that. If the person is still gravely disabled, they can go to a hearing to extend the length of hospital stay. Considering how many pills Buffy ingested, I doubt anyone would believe this wasn't a serious suicide attempt.

In terms of confidentiality, California has passed a new privacy law (HIPPA) which is much more strict. One possible way around the confidentiality issue might be if Buffy were still on Joyce's medical insurance, as many students under the age of 24 still are on their parents' insurance. However, since I've never been hospitalized for such a thing, I don't know if Buffy would have had an opportunity to speak to Joyce, or if the 72 hour hold would have taken effect as soon as she was medically stable and evaluated by a psychiatrist.

Bottom line-- It's fiction, and it was great that Buffy could finally really talk and communicate with her mom about her internal conflicts and her horrible self-esteem. I'm really looking forward to the next chapter where Buffy (hopefully) gets to talk with Spike.

Reviewer: Amy Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 03:21 am Title: Chapter 36

Well as someone who works in a mental health institution I call tell you that age varies from state to state. So a person in Michigan is an adult at 17 and is probably 18 in California.
As for a 24 hour "hold" as you put it...I think you are refferring to something equivalent to "involuntary committment" which is what would be done if someone is a harm to self or others or is not in the correct state of mind to consent. Which in this case, a suicide attempt would be harm to self and therefore counts. Which would mean that there would be an involuntary commitment with a 24 hour abservation. Although with suicide it would be more like 72.
COnfidentiality is TRICKY. I would just say suspend belief and write what you want. The laws on this are convuluded and messy and who wants to read that?

Lasty, great story. I'm enjoying it thus far. And if you are doing a mental health angle and need any further infor let me know!

PS: I just got off of a 12 hour shift at the facility I work where I got beat up and had to stop a patient from self mutilating. THerefore please excuse ant spelling or grammatical errors :)

Reviewer: sara m Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 03:16 am Title: Chapter 36

I don't think the chapter was too long, there was a lot the needed to be said. great as always

Reviewer: PhotographyNut Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 01:55 am Title: Chapter 36

Wondering how much Joyce is going to tell Giles, if anything, and how they'll react towards Spike! Great chapter!

Reviewer: MidnightGirl Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 12:25 am Title: Chapter 36

Great update! I can't wait to find out what happens when William shows up.

Reviewer: Madame Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/30/2006 - 12:01 am Title: Chapter 36

I love the angst.

Reviewer: secretguest Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/29/2006 - 09:03 pm Title: Chapter 36

So what's gonna happen next when Will comes? Update soon please!

Reviewer: Crystal Pegasus Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/29/2006 - 08:22 pm Title: Chapter 36

So glad she got that all out in the open. I hope when William gets there, she'll really talk to him and he'll really listen and they CAN start over, or at least find a mutual ground to start from cause I know that he really really loves her and I think she really loves him too, she's just too screwed up to see it fully yet, but admitting all that to her mom is a great starting place to heal from. Great chap and I don't mind any "legal" inconsistencies cause very state/country is difference in how they deal with attempted suicide so I'll buy anything you want to put in the tale, i'm gullible that way. Just get those two kids back together again! Thanks for the great update! more please.

Reviewer: Meagan Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/29/2006 - 07:14 pm Title: Chapter 36

Liked the chapter and glad everything is out in the open now. Its good Buffy wants to try and fix things with Spike, but she really painted him in a bad light with her mother, when none of this, her situation, etc, are his fault. Yea he said some not nice things to her, but she made him feel cheap. I just hope Joyce doesn't start treating Spike badly.

Other then that ,nice chapter.

Reviewer: Cas Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/29/2006 - 07:06 pm Title: Chapter 36

I really like this story, but for a dissenting review - I found this chapter really hard to read becasue I couldn't believe such a frank conversation between post suicidal daughter and her mom. - esp. coming out all at once like that. Maybe Buffy was still loopy from the drugs in her system, but to me her confession wouldhave seemed more natural made to Spike. Guess its just my own hang ups coming through.

Reviewer: Laura Liz Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/29/2006 - 05:23 pm Title: Chapter 36

liked the update, and yeah, it makes sense to get the explaination out all at once. spike next?? :)

Reviewer: cordykitten Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/29/2006 - 05:14 pm Title: Chapter 36

Again: I would love the most a LJ comm and the second best a yahoo group :)
Buffy forced a smile... for her not everything is OK now like Joyce seems to believe. And she told Joyce everything, really everything. I hope that will help her start her healing process. This was a good training too for having to tell Spike the same. Loved the chapter :)

Reviewer: MAc 1 Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/29/2006 - 05:11 pm Title: Prologue and Chapter One

That should have read 'be glad you're NOT dealinig with federal wlefare...' I hate these tiny review boxes. :-)

You must login (register) to review.