Reviews For Forbidden Passion
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Ariadne Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 04:43 pm Title: Chapter 18

I love your story! :)
Yeah, maybe Buffy is a bitch, so what? I'd probably feel the same, all those lies, sadness, unhappy love, guilt, and confusion. Her bitchiness has reasons. Riley is safe and boring, and he will stay with her like forever. Spike is the opposite, and she doesn't know if she should take a chance or not, he might leave her again. But I don't think he would, because he has strong feelings for her and after all he tried to get in touch with her, but Joyce put his letters, gift and stuff aside. But only because she cared, but I still think she was over-protective.
Please continue your wonderful story, I'm loving every bit of it! :) You´re a great author!
/ Ariadne

Author's Response: I am so happy to find out that no one else agrees with the previous comments about Buffy's behavior. Ok, so maybe one reader misread it, there's no reason for me to torture my faithful readers and withhold chapters for a while. Probably couldn't have done it anyway! Thank you so much, Ariadne. As always, your review has brightened my day.

Reviewer: Sam Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 02:57 pm Title: Chapter 18

Please don't give up or take a break or whatever you want to call it. You had an idea and you should stick with it. Obviously if no-one was reading then hey cut your losses but people are and we may not all agree with you all the time but hell how boring would that be and we have tooing and froing in the reviews (which I really like) and if we all thought the same we'd all be writing the same - and I can't. I read for enjoyment and if I don't enjoy I give up and I have but I'm not - other's aren't - that's just your cold making you feel like crap. Chin up and give us that next chapter - please.

Author's Response: Hey Sam, after much consideration on the break, I realized that there probably wouldn't be a chance in hell of that happening anyway. While this story may not be every one's cup of tea, it has me by the short hairs and refuses to let go until finished. Thanks you so much for the thoughtful comments, they made me smile and since I am at work, that's a tough thing to do.

Reviewer: Toni Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 01:48 pm Title: Chapter 18

I thought you brought that across very well. I for one will keep reading.

Author's Response: Happy to hear it, Toni. Glad my point wasn't as confusing as I thought it might be. Those darned cold medicines make your mind all woozy sometimes. LoL! Thanks for the review!

Reviewer: Sarah Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 12:46 pm Title: Chapter 18

I have been enjoying this story all along. Of course I wish the path to true love was an easy one but then the story would be short. I think you have done a good job in conveying why Buffy would be reluctant to give her heart to Spike again. One bitten twice shy is a cliche for a reason.

Author's Response: Yes, it would be one hell of a short story if everything had of just flowed along smoothly. Not to mention, it wouldn't be marked under angst, right? Thank you so much, Sarah.

Reviewer: spuffygurl Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 12:37 pm Title: Chapter 18

I am enjoying this story. Please do not take a break. I can see that Buffy is truly dealing with abandonment issues. She always has. Especially when it came to her relationship with Spike. You are portraying a true self Buffy. I get frustrated with her as I did watching the TV show. I also sympathize with her like I did while watching the TV show. I think you are doing a wonderful job. As long as we end up with a huge Spuffy finale in this story I think everything will be fine. Trust me I have read stories where she is a lot more callous. Keep on going with the way your going. You are the author and all authors know what they are doing.

Author's Response: After a much needed long soak in a hot bubble bath, I realized that there was no way my muse was going to let me take a break anyway. Good news for you, huh? That said, the next update more than likely won't be up until next week. I really am going to try to work on an update on my other story or my readers there are going to flog me. I am so happy to hear that the majority of my readers understood what I was trying to convey with Buffy and agree with me. Yes, she's being hateful to Spike and only used him for her pleasure. Hello...wasn't that the whole point to their relationship in Season 6? She sure as hell didn't respect him or his feelings then, but we all stuck around for that disaster. Thank you for the review!

Reviewer: txjmfan Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 12:16 pm Title: Chapter 18

Maybe where the power of some negative reviews have made you take a step back & re-evaluate, possible one positive one can make you not have to. (*And, this coming from someone who left a ranting review for the previous chapter about how un-sorry I feel for Buffy.) I don't think you need to re-evaluate what you are trying to convey. I know you appeased my irritation with Buffy with that first statement she made to Willow. I even understand the abandonment issues. I completely get where you're coming from. I mean, Buffy is a human being. She has faults & feelings. Feelings are never pretty. They don't always make sense and they can be known to cause people to make unwise decisions that make no sense to anyone else. Granted, I think her abandonment issues where Spike is concerned are misplaced. She needs to place that blame on the doorstep of dear old Mom. Yes, he left that first night they were together, but that was to comply with her mom & make things easier on Buffy. He didn't abandon her. I mean, damn! The man wrote letters that her Mom never gave her! I don't understand how that could lead to such a warped view of love. I know she will eventually wake up & realize that the reason that it's so exciting to be around Spike is because she is totally completely in love with him. This chapter went a long way into helping me understand Buffy's mindset. Do I still wish WIllow would just speechify & tell her what she thinks as far as the Spike situation goes so that Buffy will have an epiphany and beg forgiveness of Spike & run into his arms, never to leave? YES! But, since I have faith that epiphany will happen eventually, I am being patient. I mean, the saying is true: "The path to true love is never true." I personally love this story and the way you have painted the characters, flaws and all. Really, hoping for more soon. (*I realize this may have changed with the additional note, but in the author's note at the beginning? Did you mean only two-three more chapters for us to read or for you to write?)

Author's Response: Hey there! First of all, I will not be taking a long hiatus, maybe just a week to suss out what I want to happen in the next chapter. After much reconsideration, I realized that muse wouldn't let me totally quit for a while. She's far to persistant and is gnawing at the bit to start the next installment. Yes, there will only be 2-3 chapters left. I am amazed that it is almost over, but I honestly didn't expect it to be this long anyway. Thank you so much for the review, it was awesome and made me feel much better. Glad to hear that pretty much all of my fandom understood what I was trying to convey with Buffy's action. I also agree that Willow should just put on her Resolve face and tell Buffy how it's gonna be, but I think that I am going to leave that to dear old Mom. Need to get her back into ya'lls good graces anyhow. Thanks again!

Reviewer: desertrose Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 11:56 am Title: Chapter 18

You wanna know something? Some of us are tired of stories where Buffy instantly dumps Angel or Riley because the guy she loves is evil and all of the sudden she sees the light within three hours of meeting a guy she snarked with and then wanted to shag. That type of story is just...well its not fun. There is a reason the character of Buffy is still going strong in American pop culture. Fan fiction that reflects her character, loyalty, strength and honest youthful faults ring true and make for great reading. So know what? Buffy being gun shy and sticking to someone out of earned loyalty and devotion wether steamy or not well hey why do you think Riley lasted more than a full season? True to character. (and yes I LOVE Spike or I would not read here.) I think this story is a breath of fresh air and really darn good. Hey look at the storm you whipped up. Good art makes one think and (many times) causes controversy in its portrayed controversy.

So stop fussing and concentrate on the wonderful layers you are taking the time to creat in this story. Thank you for your effort in writing.

Author's Response: Thank you so much, desertrose! I totally agree with you on the aspect of Buffy just dropping one guy the minute Spike shows up. I mean, even if you aren't in love with someone, there has to be some type of feeling, right? I normally think that makes a character sleazy in my book. Either way, I want this Buffy to come across as scared of a real love and clinging to the one person she knows would never hurt her. It's comforting and safe, something that Spike hasn't been; even if the hurt that was caused back then was by her mother. I am so glad to hear that you like my story just the way it is. Makes me proud. Thank again!

Reviewer: Katie Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 11:50 am Title: Chapter 18

Sweetie, I think you're conveying exactly what you're trying to convey, and doing a great job of it. I don't think Buffy is a bitch demon woman, and have never gotten that impression from this story. I hope you stick it out with this one - it's possible that the problem some people have with the story is theirs, not yours.

Author's Response: I totally agree with you, Katie. I just wanted you guys to know that I never meant to make her callous and I am elated to hear that it didn't come across that way. Thank you so much!

Reviewer: Nika Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 11:04 am Title: Chapter 18

Oh, I know she has her reasons, but I can't help but be mad at her! She broke my poor Spike's heart. Can't wait for the next chapter, I need it! Great story.

Author's Response: Thanks, Nika! Being mad at her for being stupid is fine, hell its expected. I just wanted to make sure you guys understood her point of view in the matter. While it might not make a whole hell of a lot of sense, Buffy's just being...well, Buffy. Thankfully, Spike is pretty apt to forgive her.

Reviewer: Avalon Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 10:33 am Title: Chapter 18

Well, I don't know if I just think differently from other people but I do understand Buffy. All consuming passion is really very scary, and the need for something solid in her life, that's not gonna change is understandable. Not that I agree with her, but I can understand.

Of course, she's only fooling herself, and by doing it, Riley tand Spike too. But I'm sure she'll wake up sooner or later and realize that nice has nothing compared to mind blowing passion ;)

Author's Response: Thanks for the uplifiting review, Avalon. Yes, I was worried about the general consensus of my readers and what they thought about Buffy's attitude. After reading not only yours, but all of the reviews left today, my outlook has changed considerably. Buffy is a frightened little girl at this moment and is clinging to the one stable aspect in her everchanging life. Her heart's desire will make itself known soon. I promise. Thank you so much!

Reviewer: Slayerfan Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 10:31 am Title: Chapter 18

I think you're doing a great job with your story. I'd like a little more Spuffy ;) , but other than that you should keep writing your story the way you planned it.

Author's Response: Thanks! There will be more Spuffy, soon. I promise.

Reviewer: smlcspike Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 10:22 am Title: Chapter 18

I can understand, why she is staying with Riley, and why she sent Spike away, she is running scared and as she said Riley is safe, I don't know what I want Riley to say right now at least she came clean with him.

Her relationship with Spike never really got a chance to start because of her mother and she also needs to have some kind of closer with Spike. I can understand her sleeping with Spike too, because hey never really one to talk, Spike was taken with her from the first time he saw he in Cordy's mothers bedroom, then the kisses they shared and next think they knew they were in bed together.

So her sleeping with him now can be understood, she is also scared he will leave her again so why not send him away, after all he left the first time without saying anything for her. So in a way she gave the out and she left him before anything to bad can happen.

It might help her if Spike and her were able to become friends, or something, I am not sure if they used BC, and not really sure if a Baby would be a good thing, since they said Riley and her are waiting til after being married.


I love this story and think you are just fine with it.


Author's Response: See...that's what I wanted! Right there. Where you as a reader can put yourself in her position. You can relate to the emotional whirlwind that is going on in her heart at the moment. Yes, she jumped into bed with Spike without a whole heck of a lot of thought to Riley; but, when someone cheats, do they really think about their significant other at that exact moment. I honestly don't think so, not that I have been in that position, but I have counseled many of friend in that department. Buffy's guilt came later, when the realization of what she had done hit her like a satelite falling out of the sky. She felt guilty. Remorseful, and truly ashamed of the way she had behaved. Plus, coming clean with Riley was a major step with her. It would have been very easy to just sweep it under the rug. Although I have managed to make Riley a nice guy in this story, a huge feat for me, he is eventually going to get the boot. I, for one, am a sucker for a happy Spuffy ending. Also, as far as the pregger issue. No, she's not going to get knocked up. That would be an aspect of the story that I am just not willing to go into. She's on BC, that will be mentioned later. Thanks so much!

Reviewer: Nicki Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 10:08 am Title: Chapter 18

Dude, I think how you are portraying Buffy is completely honest! I mean, her Dad bailed on her, Spike crushed her when she was her most vulnerable and having it thrown at her that he was waiting for her, doesn't change all the years of her waiting and trying to heal. She basically spent years getting over him and is completely tired of the constant drama that surrounds everything he represents. Of course, Riley will look like what she thinks "love" should be. She has seen what unblinding faith in a man that you love can do to a person, i.e. her mother, so she hasn't figured it out yet. Don't let people keep you from writing what you believe to be the true character. You are spot on my dear!

Author's Response: Thanks, Nicki. I have been totally blown away by the positive response. After getting that one bad comment my mood was bordering on despondent with a side order of anger. Now, I can totally see that I was being paranoid. Thank you so much for helping me see that. Thanks again!

Reviewer: PamS Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 09:39 am Title: Chapter 18

Ah, the "Spike lovers like myself" are mad that Buffy, not you, is living up to her normal behavior.. cut and run to safe Riley. Know you are taking it personally. But you us Spikeaholics get into character just like it was happening and will be upset with which ever one is being the poop head.

That's what you wanted- right?

And the game.. sorry. Last second as usual. I still think Alabama will kick their butt. That Coach.. no names given.. has them looking good. LSU is a little lackluster to me- not a smooth running machine.

Hope you feel better. Waiting to see how you get our pair back together.

Author's Response: Being a "Spikelover" myself, I totally understand what you are saying. I also get irritated when Buffy acts like a total buttmunch. (Yep, pulled that straight out of 1987.) I was just worried that what I was trying to accomplish with her feelings wasn't quite getting the job done. After reading your review (and email) as well as like everyone elses, I realized that I was just being hyper sensitive. So far, it seems like only one reader in particular had a problem with what I was doing and I can certainly handle that. As far as the game goes, I was honestly expecting to have our asses handed to us on a paper plate. Even though we lost at the last moment, I am proud of my boys for not letting LSU run slap over them. It was a great game, that's for sure. Thanks so much, Pam!

Reviewer: Angi Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/25/2007 - 08:13 am Title: Chapter 18

Hmmm, this Buffy IS flaky, because she never told RIley or Spike what´s really inside. She is lying all the time, the only conversation that sounded half-way to truthful was the one she had with Willow, and even in that one, she lied to herself.
There is no logic behind anything, either. If what she had with Spike has the ability to leave that dark hole inside and almost kills you when he leaves, how can it not be love? And if it´s extreme like that, how can she not acknowledge, that she is doing exactly that to Spike now, that although he did nothing wrong, she hurts him the same way now, uncaring?
How can she claim to love Riley, when she didn´t give one thought to him while falling into Spike´s bed? You simply don´t do that to someone you love, especially if you don´t love the other much more.
I get what you wanted to achieve with Buffy´s actions, but you´ve made her something worse than shallow, you made her a selfish, uncaring, two-timing liar. Is that really better?


Author's Response: Angi, I am truly sorry that you find not only my story, but writing style to be illogical. I tried to portray Buffy as a confused college coed who just had her life disrupted by the reappearance of her first love. She has been hurt in the past by many men, not to mention the whole issue of dealing with the mistrust she now has with her mother. I never intended for her to come across as selfish or uncaring, and personally, I don't think I did. If she were uncaring, then I don't believe she would have felt guilt or remorse for cheating on Riley. Yes, she did cheat. I cannot condone that, but it was crucial to the story. She shared something with Spike that she had not shared with Riley. I am sorry if that offended you, but I will not apologize for writing my story the way I want to. It is a sad fact that people do cheat on their significant others even when they care for them. Hate to say it, but it's true. The word adultery was made for such a reason. After your review, I asked my other readers for their honest opinions and I have to say that out of all my loyal reviewers, I have found only you to have a problem or any confusion as to what I was trying to convey. I am very sorry for that. Thank you anyway for taking the time to review, I do like to hear from all of my readers. I sincerely hope that you stick with me and see where my story takes you.

Reviewer: txjmfan Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/20/2007 - 06:52 am Title: Chapter 17

STUPID GIRL! OOPS! Did I just say that? Sorry, but just have to have an indignant rant on Spike's behalf? Who can blame Spike for hating her right now? Hell, he laid out his honest emotions to her, admitted he's been pining for her all this time and what does she do? Just throws it back in his face and lies to him about her feelings to boot! THEN she has the nerve to feel sorry for herself and wallow in a sob-fest! Could someobody just slap her? Please? I mean, this is all of her making. All she has to do is just admit it & save everyone heartache. Well, maybe not Riley, but who cares about him? This is Spuffy, anyway! I know, I know. If she did that there wouldn't be a wonderful fan fic to enjoy, but you can't blame a girl for wanting her Spuffy to be happy and fluffy and amorous, right?

Okay, rant over (I think). Great chaper. Actually, probably didn't have to say that. It's pretty much a given with the empassioned rant it just inspired. Excellent writing. Maybe needs a little more betaing, but otherwise installment to your tale. Looking forward to the next chapters.

Author's Response: Nicely performed rant! Thank you so much for the wonderful review. Spike's not so much with the hating, just upset for the moment. Buffy's being an irritating bitch and that's just rude, but she's going to have a change of heart eventually. Thanks again!

Reviewer: zombiegirl Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/20/2007 - 05:32 am Title: Chapter 17

Loved it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Too execellent chapters. So looking forward to more.

Author's Response: Thanks! I was hoping to get the update out tonight, but work has been hectic with suicides and fights. Damn those people for getting in my way of writting.

Reviewer: sarah g Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/20/2007 - 04:40 am Title: Chapter 17

OMFG THAT STUPID BITCH!!! HOW COULD SHE TELL HIM SHE LOVES HIM??? SHE DOSNT LOVE RILEY, THATS SUCH BULLSHIT!!! i LOVE this story and am so happy that u updated. i cant believe that she did that to him, how could she break her heart like that?!?! i really hope that she realizes wat she did to him and that she loves him not riley. also i hope that she apoligizes and that they talk things through and get together. PLEASE update as soon as u can, im DYING to read wat happens next. THANX

Author's Response: Ok, take a deep...calming...breath. Now, thank you for the review! of course Buffy's going to come to her senses! I couldn't possibly leave it that way!

Reviewer: sarah g Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/20/2007 - 03:48 am Title: Chapter 16

WAT HOW COULD SHE SAY THAT????? LOVE THIS STORY, CANT WAIT TO READ MORE!! THANX!! (sorry i had wrote another, longer review yesturday but i guess it didnt go through, which sucks. this chapter rocked, though buffys crazy, u kickass)

Author's Response: Thanks so much! So sorry to hear that your other review was lost, but thanks for coming back!

Reviewer: secretguest Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/20/2007 - 02:36 am Title: Chapter 17

That was mean...very mean. Why??? Buffy's so dumb sometimes. Sigh. If I had a guy like Spike, I'd never let him go. Man. I hope she fixes this. Can't wait for more!!!

Author's Response: Please, if Spike were mine...he'd be chained to my wrist all the time. Buffy is being very mean, but there's a reason, or at least her reason which is totally insane logic, but a reason none the less. Thanks so much!

Reviewer: Hana Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/20/2007 - 01:00 am Title: Chapter 17

I really loved this chapter!!!!The end was soooo heartbreaking...poor Spike.

Author's Response: Thanks so much, Hana! I know it was a sad chappie to read, sucked writting it, honestly...but it was needed. i'll try and make Spike feel better! loL!

Reviewer: scaryscouse Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/19/2007 - 10:32 pm Title: Chapter 17

I don't hate-I love, lots of angst-more please. Getting back together shouldn't be that easy anyway

Author's Response: See...I totally love angst, love love love it! So, really glad to hear that someone else out there is just as twisted as moi! :) Glad you liked it! Thanks for the review!

Reviewer: Pyro63 Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/19/2007 - 08:17 pm Title: Chapter 17

Wow, awesome update. Loved it, and can't wait for more!

Author's Response: Thanks so much! I'm working on the next chapter, but probably wont be able to get it out until next week.

Reviewer: annie Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/19/2007 - 07:30 pm Title: Chapter 17

OH MY GOD! I can't belive she did that. Bad, bad, bad Buffy! sooo cruel to leave us hanging like this, you have to update soon, or else my faith in happy spuffy ending will slowly dwindle... :D lol, I loved the chap, sad but necessary for plot. update! update! update!


psst! update!

Author's Response: Oh, Annie...don't lose Faith! :) This story is very much scheduled to have a happy ending. Promise. Thanks so much!

Reviewer: smlcspike Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 10/19/2007 - 06:43 pm Title: Chapter 17

OH I hope someone can help make it right, for both of them. I don't know why Buffy did that. Maybe Willow can help.

Author's Response: I think Willow may be a tad bit gun shy right now! LoL! Thanks so much for the review!

You must login (register) to review.