Oh it's your seasonal_spuffy story? It's marked finished there but not here, btw.

I like the start a lot but I didn't hear Spike saying a wish either. Wishing for Buffy maybe but not saying it out loud.
*off to find out what he'd wished for*

Author's Response: Yeah it's my Seasonal_Spuffy story. I'm trying to edit it as complete but I'm not sure how to navigate this site all that well. Well, that's the idea. The lady in red can hear the heart-wish because she has powers, but it's not spoken. It's something Spike's heart wishes for in silence. Something he's not even consciously aware of.