Reviews For My Elizabeth
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Inara Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 09/09/2012 - 10:37 pm Title: Epilogue

Hey there! Sorry about the super late response... things have been a little crazy over on my end.

Thank you so much for a wonderful story and a much needed sequel to the lives of Buffy and William. This story was fantastic and I loved seeing the evolution of both Buffy and William. Although I am saddened that William had to lose some of his adorable innocence as he faced both human and real monsters, I loved his transformation and, more importantly, loved that both William and - eventually - Buffy, learned how to change together. They both realized that they truly were partners and that this partnership wasn't dependent on physical strength, but rather the strength that they found in each other. Thank you so much once again... and if a little one-shot for those to characters is rattling around in the writing genius you call a brain... *please* don't hesitate to share. ;-)

Can't wait to read more from you and I hope you have a successful move!!!

Author's Response: Thanks Inara. I was a little worried about the ending, but when the story popped into my head, this was the ending it had. And no matter how I twisted and turned, it was the ending it insisted on having. You've been such a little beam of encouragement as I wrote this and I can't thank you enough. The move, unfortunately, didn't actually happen, so I'm stuck here for a bit longer :( Hope to see you in another story soon.

Reviewer: Pierrie Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 09/09/2012 - 10:08 pm Title: Chapter 1

I have loved ''Yours, William'' and I have loved as much ''My Elisabeth''. Those stories are the reason why i still continue after so many years to look for new stories. I know that somewhere there are some that are just wonderful and that I will read again and again. Thank you so much Puddinhead for those great stories. Take all the time you need but please come back eventually with a sequel of this tale.

Author's Response: Thank you so much Pierrie. I learned a lot writing this story - a lot of mistakes that I can't help but wince when I see them. But it's so nice to know that you enjoyed it.

Reviewer: BuffyRat Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 08/28/2012 - 03:32 am Title: Epilogue

Been thinking... By high school, she could be dyed blond. :) Quite a ride. Thanks again.

Author's Response: Why not? Buffy was dying in HS!

Reviewer: BuffyRat Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 08/28/2012 - 03:28 am Title: Chapter 39

So, I wanted you to know that I read this two days ago, and just had to let it all digest before I expounded upon it, because you went and made this whole two story tale far more philosophical than I was expecting. A story about the journey, two heroes that are always ready to sacrifice everything for the world and how this journey that was supposed to save them from these trials somehow throws them right back into it. No, where they end up isn't important, but the fact that these two souls find themselves there and still give it all up once again for the world really does prove the kind of character they are made of. Two champions that are nothing if not greater than the sum of their smarts and heart. Seems to me that maybe the powers that be finally realized what great champions they had, especially when teamed up, and still manipulated them to accomplish the greater good. I have to believe that there is another place for them to be, both healthy and human... maybe their daughter is the one reading that sign... though I think we both know their daughter wouldn't likely be blond. :) And I still smile thinking of Buffy trying to "drive" that carriage. I would have to imagine automobiles offering her the same contemptuous expression.

I love knowing that Dru made it out of this disaster, with her true Billy in her head. I think there could be many wonderful tales of their antics from the past through to the, well, now. Would Billy adapt to the modern age or would he work that much harder at keeping Dru all vintage? And after all the tales Buffy told of her first lifetime in California, I really think the only fair thing to do would be to upend our almost still proper William into the world of cars, TVs, and blooming onions. A reverse world, where Buffy is the knowing entity, (though I still have my money on William more successfully garnering a drivers license.) Yes, that is where they should be. William and Buffy.

It was quite a ride. Made me think quite often and always made my day. I hope more of this or some other verse comes about one day. Your muse creates wonderful worlds to visit. May even follow it somewhere that's not Spuffy. :) Thank you so much for this one, and the bonus history lessons. It's been a pleasure.


Author's Response: Wow Buffyrat. This is a review for the ages. Thank you so much. When Joss posted on Whedonesque, right after the Avengers came out, he talked about how fistfuls of money really were nothing compared to having someone tell you that you made them laugh or made them cry. Well, fistfuls of money isn't an option for me, but that really shouldn't matter, because knowing that someone came along on the journey with you - that you touched their emotions or made them *think* really means everything to me. Thank you, humbly, for going with there with me and for letting me know about it in such a graceful way. When I'm feeling like I can't write, this is a review I'll pull out and wrap myself in like a blankey. (Like Spike's blanket, but less flammable!) Hope to see you some day soon. -P-

Reviewer: The Enemy of Reality Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/26/2012 - 08:26 pm Title: Epilogue

God damn it, Puddin, you made me cry. I couldn't have hoped for a more perfect ending. And actually, I loved the fact the ending is sort of open and lets us draw our own conclusion as to where they ended up.

They've grown throughout this story so much and to the point where William ended up being the perfect and equal partner to not just Elizabeth, but to Buffy, the Slayer.

It was a beautiful story full of heart and humour and if the world was fair, it'd be talented writers like you earning shitloads of money instead of awful writers (cough, E.L. James, cough) without a speck of imagination. I'm really looking forward to reading anything new from you, whenever that may be!!! Love your stuff.

Author's Response: THANKS. This is going to be one of those reviews that I save for days when I feel like I can't write for shit. Which is lots of days! Hope to be back with another story soon.

Reviewer: The Enemy of Reality Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/26/2012 - 08:09 pm Title: Chapter 39

Oooh, this kept me sitting at the edge of my seat from the first sentence to the last! I can't tell you how much I freaking LOVE the fact the villain are humans because I think it was a hard and a brave choice on your part, and I've always wished Joss took that same choice in S4 and made the people be villains instead of Adam. It's much more interesting this way and I just love the way you write. Can't wait to see what happens in the epilogue!!!

Author's Response: Thank you so much EoR. One of the neat perks of this story has been getting to know you (and your writing). And I agree with you. If history shows us anything, its that people can be prime monsters

Reviewer: badgervamp Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/26/2012 - 01:58 am Title: Epilogue

Awesome, awesome story. Enjoyed it every step of the way. Original and believable interpretations of Elizabeth/ Buffy and William's characters and motivations and insight into their evolving relationship. Great work. I hope inspiration hits you again - I'd love to see a sequel one day!!

Author's Response: Thank you so much(I get a mental picture of Badger from Breaking Bad, turned vampire!) Hope to have another Spuffy story some day

Reviewer: ScarlettDuck Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/25/2012 - 05:48 pm Title: Chapter 39

So gorgeous. Love that they're working together and appreciating each other. Also love that you used the phrase "a murder of crows!" Have always loved that collective name. I watched the video q & a's on James Marsters' official site, and in one of them, he's asked what his favorite emotion is and he says "exaltation." He goes on to say that when a group of small birds take flight all at the same time, it's called an "exaltation of birds" and that he thinks it's a good description of what the heart does when in the moment of exaltation. Love that, too! =)

Author's Response: It's great that you liked murder of crows. I was trying to think of something *like* butterflies in the tummy but intense and unpleasant. :) Thank you again for your feedback, for myself and other writers too. It keeps us goin

Reviewer: ScarlettDuck Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/25/2012 - 04:50 pm Title: Epilogue

Love it.

I'd love to see what happened to them... would have liked to see William get even closer to Spike's badassery and confidence; one of the things I like most about Spike is his love of the fight, how he likes to fight alongside Buffy, how much he respects and gets excited about Buffy's prowess... William got closer to that, but while he admires Buffy's power and skill, he's still reluctant to fight or to watch her fight, while Spike revels in it.

Ultimately, as much as I'd like to find out how they fared, I'm ok with the open-ended conclusion as I can choose to imagine an ending to my own preferences... since Buffy went back to William's time originally to give him what he deserves, part of me feels like the PTB are just being dicks here if they felt like the difficult row Buffy & he had to hoe was what he deserved. But then maybe they wanted him to be able to die a hero again... maybe that's what would fulfull him the most.

Great story, thank you!

Author's Response: Thank you SD. Yes, I understand what you mean about Spike's badassery. Here he was the "thinker" of the duo and in the previous tale he'd begun to fight a little bit. Thanks for the feedback.

Reviewer: SeaPea Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/25/2012 - 01:05 am Title: Epilogue

Fabulous job. I thought the ending was perfect. You accomplished everything you set out to do on chronicling their respective journeys. And I learned a lot of history on top of it! Well done.

Author's Response: Thank you seapea! Hope the history wasn't too ... teacherish :)

Reviewer: ace Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/24/2012 - 03:24 pm Title: Epilogue

Fantastic. It was all about the journey. I love how much Buffy grew throughout both tales. So confident in herself as a woman and as a slayer. She and William were in it for the long haul - for forever. I it supremely unlikely that they did not end up in another time or dimension, given how Buffy ended up back in the 1800's in the first place. I cannot imagine Sunnydale without a hellmouth. Thanks for sharing. I loved the ride and looked forward to your updates.

Author's Response: Thanks so much for the feedback, ace. Readers like you keep me (and lots of authors) going. Now that I'm not writing it, I don't know what to do with myself!

Reviewer: Passion4Spike Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/24/2012 - 02:06 pm Title: Epilogue

I hope one day your muse tells you what happens to Buffy and William, I know we'd all love to know. And I fully agree that inside William was always a hero's heart just waiting for someone to allow him to show it. Love this spuffy couple - lovely story.

Ok, you asked for negatives - I have only one thing I would've changed: At the end I would've loved a longer goodbye with many, many more tears, thoughts of dashed dreams, unborn children, lost potential, perhaps guilt on Buffy's part for coming back and bringing William here, etc.

Overall, of course, I loved the story and hope we hear more from them sometime in the future.

Brava!

Author's Response: Yes, and THANK YOU. I love constructive criticism. That would have been a nice touch - to think of the unborn children etc. If I had it to write again I would like to try it with an aside to William thinking these thoughts. Partly, he was under a time constraint. Also, I saw him at that moment of being very ... selfless. And when I got in his head, tried to think his thoughts. He was just in that moment for me at that time. But you make a great point. Thanks for sticking it out with me :)

Reviewer: Passion4Spike Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/24/2012 - 01:53 pm Title: Chapter 39

Of course Buffy and William's love would be the thing they'd need to sacrifice, yet again, for the world. I hope sometime in the future your muse will be inspired to show us where they went - or perhaps the epilogue will tell us. I keep coming back to: if the Hellmouth didn't open, then did Buffy ever even come to Sunnydale as a teen - did she ever even meet Spike, etc. Time-travel scenarios make me crazy-mad. :) Lovely story - I'm very sorry to see it end.

Sorry the link to the playlist didn't work. :(

Author's Response: Well, I always have a problem posting links and embedding things - but thanks for trying! Yeah, time-travel can mess with your head. I tend to think of it in alternative universes or it makes my brain all scrambly. Thank you again for your support

Reviewer: Nana Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/24/2012 - 04:12 am Title: Epilogue

This was great! I like where you left it. Thank you.

Author's Response: Thank you so much Nana!

Reviewer: ScarlettDuck Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/07/2012 - 09:45 am Title: Chapter 38

Wow, another great chapter ... looking forward to more!

Author's Response: Thank you sweetie!

Reviewer: ScarlettDuck Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/07/2012 - 09:30 am Title: Chapter 37

Love this happy little chapter. I realize the happiness may not continue unimpeded, so I'll just savor it for a few minutes.

And I have always loved Oscar, but haven't read nearly enough about him. Your factoid about his subversive little society makes me love him ever so much more! And his mom, too!

Author's Response: Thanks SD! Yeah, I ended up being fasinated with Oscar. I'll be honest, researching him was a joy and I had to force myself to stop reading about him and write already!

Reviewer: BuffyRat Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 08/07/2012 - 02:19 am Title: Chapter 38

Sometimes our history appalls me. I suppose that's why we must study it. And then you give me something about William crashing over the "Welcome to Sunny Dale" sign in a carriage! All facets of wonderful here. And mayor Wilkins. Hope to see more of this soon and that the move doesn't whoop your ass too much. :)

Author's Response: Hey Buffyrat. Well I try not to be too preachy about it, but I'm glad that you find it interesting too. When I was researching it while visiting relatives in Wyoming, I bored them shitless with details about it!

Reviewer: The Enemy of Reality Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/04/2012 - 07:04 pm Title: Chapter 38

I always enjoy your author's notes. You feed my inner history nerd. :) And as someone who moves around a lot, I have to ask... don't you just hate it when boxes full of stuff still pop up weeks and weeks after you've already moved in and unpacked? Why does that happen?!

Oh, William, so concerned about Buffy's breasts. *snickers* That amused me to no end! And the eeriness of the old SunnyD. Man, LOVED the descriptions because you write them so well and vividly. All the awards you got were well deserved. I sure as hell voted for you. ;)

Btw, this made me legit shudder. 'The earlier sensation of prickles along her back grew more pronounced, as if a metal spider were patrolling along her spine.' Aaah, creepy visual. I loved it.

Can't believe this story's almost over because I'm going to miss being excited for a new chapter. But at the same time, it's been amazing and I can't wait for the grand finale!!! :)

Author's Response: You're too nice to me and I don't deserve you. I know this. Just letting you know that. Thanks so much for the juicy review. I love the things you pull out that you like because you're the only person that likes them! That I know of! And I love that. Having trouble with the next chapter but chipping away at it, like at an iceberg with a toothpick. A METAL toothpick tho! What are you working on lately anyway?

Reviewer: Passion4Spike Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/04/2012 - 04:03 am Title: Chapter 38

Moving again!? Oh no! What have you done to anger the gods? Glad you're happy to move back, but I couldn't imagine two moves so quickly. Good luck! So, Dru has an army of vamps, but the Mayor and the Reverend just have regular people? Will Buffy kill humans? Even horrid ones? I guess we'll find out.

Author's Response: NOT excited about the act of moving. I have actual nightmares about it. Last time the moving co paid damages on our sofa, bookshelf, washing machine, refrigerator and ... it goes on. Plus... my son in HS. Plus ... GOD I don't wanna do this. On the other hand, I really wanna get out of Missouri. You ask good questions. Answers next! Thanks for sharing your thougts

Reviewer: ace Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/04/2012 - 02:27 am Title: Chapter 38

Fred Phelps! I went to law school in Topeka and he would picket the school because we had *gasp* professors who were gay.

Author's Response: He seemed a natural fit. Hating "differentness" for 100 years (and making a pact with evil to stay alive). Thanks Ace!

Reviewer: SeaPea Anonymous Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/04/2012 - 02:22 am Title: Chapter 38

Just glad that William started the tradition of mowing down the Sunnydale sign.

Author's Response: What's funny is that didn't occur to me until the last possible second! Thanks!

Reviewer: Inara Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/04/2012 - 12:25 am Title: Chapter 38

THE MAYOR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Okay, okay so yeah, he's totally one of my favorite Buffy villains. I see no reason why evil can't be courteous. Rude and evil are in fact mutually exclusive things. I'm a dork, I know.

Is the Mayor the white demon? I know we're in a split off/alternative universe, so I assume that if Buffy kills the mayor now it won't have an effect on her defeat of him at the school??? Right??? Sorry - probably way more than you wanted to think about. Anyway, I can't wait to see how Dru's army works with the Mayor and why she was oddly coherent about what is going on. There is still the question of who Billy is? Is he the First? 'Cuz Billy in real life wasn't that smart and definitely not omnipotent. Curiouser and curiouser. Although, gotta say, poor Buffy is she has to face that big bad again.

Can't wait to see what happens! Thanks again.

Also - I'm glad you get to move back "home". Although, having just moved myself, I sympathize.

Author's Response: Thank you again Inara, for your excellent feedback. I need to more clearly define who Billy is (the first? a spook? her mind?) and I will do that. Someone commenting on EF made me include the Mayor. Feedback, I will humbly admit, totally changes this story. It is absolutely collaborative. The white demon thing will be made absolutely clear too. I will say that ... William's dream on the hill. Pretty accurate foretelling. Hugs! Thanks so much for your input hon!

Reviewer: Inara Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 08/04/2012 - 12:05 am Title: Chapter 37

Hey there - Remember me??? Sorry about the lack of response. I've just moved.... Argh! What a nightmare. Remind me not to do that again anytime soon. Trying to get cable and internet hooked-up - seemingly impossible for the cable and internet technician. Although, it did give me plenty of opportunities to watch the Buffster and Spike and William - I'm such a sucker for "Fool for Love". I swear my DVD is going to die one day from watching it too much!

Anyway, back to you and your lovely story. The only thing I have to say to you is "Did you get possessed by Oscar Wilde?" I swear you are spot-on. So many things you have him say or the way you make him act is totally how I picture him. AND I absolutely adore that you have Buffy be the inspiration for Dorian Grey!! Nice reaction to Bram Stoker as well! ;-)

What plans do the couple have for the Hellmouth....? I'm so glad the next chapter is already up! Thanks again for you great story.

Author's Response: Hell yes I remember you. I look forward to hearing your insight. When you didn't respond, I wasn't so concerned that you thought it sucked as I was "I wonder if everything is ok with Inara." I'm relieved that things are (ok). Ugh...moving? GOD I hate it. I used to have nightmares about it. I'm trying to be up about the (possibly) impending one because I hate where I live now and love where the move would return me to. I hope your move has been a good one. I will confess, I LOVED Oscar. The more I read of him and about him, the more there was to love. It was hard to say goodbye, but on the upside, my original outline had Dru killing him on the Hellmouth.

Reviewer: The Enemy of Reality Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/20/2012 - 06:14 pm Title: Chapter 37

Aaaah, the brilliance of working in the Bram Stoker just tickled me! :D And it was a very interesting tidbit I didn't know about. One of many, many reason why I LOVE this story so much.

Oh yeah, who wouldn't remember Uncle Thomas and the hilarious dumping of the pudding right on his head. :D

Author's Response: Thanks EoR! I didn't know a lot of this stuff either - and when I found it out while researching, I got VERY excited. Esp. about the Dracula connection!

Reviewer: Passion4Spike Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 07/20/2012 - 05:58 pm Title: Chapter 37

Your stories are always enlightening! Love the end notes! And this chapter was especially entertaining - quite funny throughout layered with sweetness. Loved all the quotes and Oscar 'stealing' a saying from Buffy! Cool tie-in with Bram Stoker, too! And just what did you have to do to join the 'Society for the Prevention of Virtue' and where do we sign up? I'll also miss Oscar - you did an extraordinary job with him! Now on to the Hellmouth, I presume? Not feeling great about this ... fingers crossed!

Author's Response: I'm glad that you don't know what's going to happen next! That's my goal - to not telegraph it. It was nearly as difficult to say goodbye to Oscar as it was to kill Billy. Originally Oscar was to be killed by Dru at the Hellmouth, but in the end, I couldn't bring myself to it. Big Chicken. Thanks for your support and feedback.

You must login (register) to review.